Recent Posts
Home >Unlabelled > Will Deadline's Hollywood Reporter Suit Redefine Copyright In The Internet Age? on Astini News
Will Deadline's Hollywood Reporter Suit Redefine Copyright In The Internet Age? on Astini News
Posted on Thursday, September 22, 2011 by astini
Will Deadline's Hollywood Reporter Suit Redefine Copyright In The Internet Age?
Sept. 14, 2011, 10:32 PM EST
By Lucas Shaw & Brent LangTheWrap
Nikki Finke may be known as having chutzpah to spare, but Deadline's lawsuit against The Hollywood Reporter goes where few newsrooms have gone before, demanding $5 million for "stealing" its scoops.
In the internet age of aggregation, where the lifespan of an "exclusive" can be measured in seconds, attorneys say Penske Media Corp., Deadline's parent, faces an uphill fight to make its lawsuit stick.
"You can't stop the world from using information you report," said Thomas R. Julin, a First Amendment specialist at Hunton & Williams. "But if [THR] is simply grabbing that in some mechanical fashion, taking it and republishing it as their own, there might be some tort."
Also read: Why Nikki Finke's Content Theft Lawsuit Is Interesting, If Still Batty
In a response to the lawsuit, THR released a statement that basically said, that's how news gets reported around here.
"An initial review of the complaint shows that it is replete with examples of stories that originated from widely-released press releases from publicists, or widespread confirmations from publicists to numerous outlets, including both The Hollywood Reporter and Deadline.com," went the statement. "It is not copyright infringement to report these stories, even if on occasion Deadline.com posts them first."
But if Deadline were to prevail in court over the claims of copyright infringement, it would upend the way that media organizations chase breaking news in the age of the web.
Lawyers say that PMC cannot argue that it owns the news and instead must demonstrate that the Hollywood Reporter systematically parroted Deadline's reporting without performing any independent verification.
Also read: Hollywood Reporter Calls Bull on Nikki Finke News Theft, Will Check on Copied Code
The suit lists dozens of stories where the Reporter's version was posted less than an hour after Deadline, and asserts that Reporter employees "continue to engage in a practice of closely monitoring Deadline's website minute-by-minute for the specific purpose of spotting key news stories and original content and reproducing them."
That alone is not sufficient evidence to win a copyright infringement case, say the experts.
To prove its claims, Penske will have to conduct discovery, which would entail extensive research into how the Reporter collects its information.
That could then give THR an opportunity to inspect Deadline's operation -- which the secretive Finke would probably be loath to permit.
Over decades media companies have rarely taken their gripes about stealing scoops into court, so there is little legal precedent for Penske's attorneys to draw on.
Since the internet revolution, there have been only a handful of court cases and none of them have done much to clarify the difference between aggregating and outright theft.
Also read: Nikki Finke to THR: 'Get the F--- Out of My Face'
One landmark case was The Associated Press v. All Headline News Corp., which advanced the so-called "hot news" doctrine. That law restricts news organizations from unconstrained lifting of reporting done by competitors. (The aggregator settled the case with AP.)
But a more recent case complicated the picture, as a court ruled in favor of financial newswire service flyonthewall.com, arguing that banks could not stop the site from immediately reporting on analysts' recommendations. The distinction here is that a site cannot reprint someone else's content, but it can report on that content.
Neither of these cases provide a clear legal framework for Deadline, which uses legal terms like "free ride" that are associated with the hot news doctrine, but cites no legal precedents.
The "free ride" reference is usually used to prevent companies from reproducing and profiting off another site's reporting without investing in their own newsgathering. That, the thinking goes, unfairly puts competitors at a financial disadvantage.
"Form the perspective of the courts, if you allow companies to exist parasitically off of other people's newsgathering they'll go out of business," said Andrew Deutsch, an attorney at DLA Piper, who also worked on The Associated Press and flyonthewall.com cases.
However, even proving that is quite a challenge.
"For the law to intervene, it has to be in someone's business model to not hire reporters and to copy other sites content and copy it all the time," Deutsch added.
THR, like many other sites, may be in the business of aggregating, but it has its own reporters and much of its content is original. Even two of the stories cited in the suit exhibit original reporting from a THR employee.
None of its stories give any credit to Deadline for its original reporting, but legal experts do not seem to believe that is enough to demonstrate copyright infringement, particularly as the stories in question focus on factual minutiae such as release dates and executive reshuffling.
Penske's case may more solidly rest on allegations that the Reporter's spiffy new home page directly lifted coding from its TVLine.com. THR has already removed one of the designs in questions from its site, and said it would investigate the allegation.
"There's a huge disparity in the strength of their claims," said Shyam Balganesh, professor of law at University of Pennsylvania.
Though Penske took the steps to copyright that coding, according to the suit, it is common practice for web developers to borrow liberally from other JavaScript sites. Of course, the same goes for aggregating content.
Common practice, in the case of web development, may still be illegal.
That means Prometheus may be writing a check to Jay Penske even if a court decides that THR did the leg work to confirm that "Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol" would indeed be released in time for Christmas.
Related Articles from TheWrap:
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(2934)
-
▼
September
(682)
- This familyâs favourite kitchen tool is a comput...
- News - The Neshoba Democrat on Astini News
- News: Mozambique proposes law to axe VAT on animal...
- Try Thanksgiving in Belize, Says The Lodge at Chaa...
- The Origin Of The Word 'Epilepsy' : NPR on Astini ...
- Arizona to host GOP presidential debate in Decembe...
- Schizophrenia - Pipeline Review, H2 2011 on Astini...
- Nicolas Cage on 'The Expendables 2' and 'Ghost Rid...
- Who deserves 2011 PGA Tour Player of the Year hono...
- Lille midfielder Joe Cole targets England recall o...
- What is Sonic the Hedgehog Without a Sega Console?...
- Salespeople at three Bob's Discount Furniture stor...
- on Astini News
- Stocks ending gloomy 3rd quarter on a weak note - ...
- BLABBERMOUTH.NET on Astini News
- Does it work? Can maca increase sexual appetite? -...
- Giants trying to avoid 'trap' vs. Cardinals on Ast...
- Sharpshooting Fairfield detective places 11th on H...
- Obama's race problem is black and white -- and gre...
- Premier League football news from the Barclays Pre...
- HBO Marketing Chief Courteney Monroe to Step Down ...
- 750 pieces of John Wayne's life on the block - Loc...
- Present-Day Republican Rage Pre-Dates the Tea Part...
- Frances Bean Cobain | Frances Bean Cobain Turns To...
- OS X Lion / Snow Leopard Now Required to play 'Cit...
- Nassau County detective quitting over allegation s...
- Daniel Radcliffe A 'Star Wars' Virgin - Entertainm...
- Google Fights German Lawsuit Over âSex-Club Bill...
- New ACDSee Photo Editing and Management Products D...
- ROM â @nickmcminn60 MIUI SS-8 âLG 2X Editionâ...
- George Clooney Defends Ex Elisabetta Canalis From ...
- IRONCLAD (2011) on Astini News
- Actors Who Should Win And Who Will Win (PHOTOS) on...
- Young Canadians are creating a better world on Ast...
- Nine Named Semifinalists For 2012 Kentucky Teacher...
- Be Trafalgarâs guest by watching Better Homes & ...
- Grocery stores expanding generic brands on Astini ...
- Summer over, Cape road work abounds on Astini News
- Charles Manson and Me: A Memoir on Astini News
- Your Kidâs Brain, SpongeBob-ed | NewAmerica.net ...
- Extreme Weather Leads To Spike In Sales on Astini ...
- Australia ruling in Apple vs Samsung case expected...
- Titan Medical Inc. Announces Memorandum of Underst...
- DAILY YOMIURI ONLINE (The Daily Yomiuri) on Astini...
- A gluten-free for all drives product sales | Reute...
- Space Shuttle Enterprise Unveiled 35 Years Ago to ...
- Prime Limousine, Audi sign deal on 100 Audis for E...
- South Africa ponders issuing visa for Dalai Lama o...
- 'We the People' captures American spirit | MyCentr...
- on Astini News
- Neil Youngâs book deal sparks hunt for Canadian ...
- The Sweet Smell of Easier Weight Loss? on Astini News
- Living | Angry Birds game may top holiday toy sale...
- SEC probes RBS,Credit Suisse over bad mortgage loa...
- Top 100 ALA Banned Books: Harry Potter | The Back ...
- I-Team 10 investigation: Pizzeria employee accused...
- US scientists testing earthquake early warning - T...
- Holy Land 9/3/11 - Celebrity Review by tigershark1...
- J. Cole on His Albumâs Eleventh-Hour Jay-Z Verse...
- Bowling for a Cause - Yahoo! Finance on Astini News
- Car Charging Group to Provide EV Charging Services...
- PR-USA.net on Astini News
- Arkham City Xbox 360 Bundle Shows Up on German Ama...
- Braylon Edwards has knee procedure, out a while - ...
- Tea Party Group to Form Super PAC on Astini News
- New Jersey Mining Company Intersects 5.07 g/t Gold...
- 'Your Highness' is supposed to be stupid; it succe...
- Analyzing The Price-To-Cash-Flow Ratio - Yahoo! Fi...
- : Movies :: News :: Paste on Astini News
- ASIC to review broker capital rules: report | News...
- Portuguese Man o' War threat underestimated by swi...
- UK professor 'reconstructs' lost Beethoven piece |...
- Award-winning producer Jon Blair joins Aljazeera o...
- Diablo 3 Community Site Offers Peak at Game's Trea...
- Valencia vs. Chelsea: Champions League Match Will ...
- Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy would have been so mu...
- Anna Faris answers film question "What's Your Numb...
- Guild Wars 2 Closed Beta Still Coming This Year --...
- Listen To The Weeknd Remix Of Florence + The Machi...
- Blackberry Mom: Shel Silverstein truly inspiring o...
- Deal watch: Norwegian Cruise Line launches another...
- AQM Announces the Discovery of the New Victoria Po...
- Ludacris, Bay City Rollers hit town in November on...
- Kim Kardashian leaves wedding ring home - Entertai...
- Voting important for youth - EEC on Astini News
- Buy Dish TV; target price raised, stock is getting...
- Weather Underground Launches Its New Weather API P...
- A victory for common sense on Astini News
- The top Typing Games Every Kid Have to Have! â E...
- Game: "Martians Vs. Goblins" F. Tyler The Creator ...
- Column: With Bielema playing ârespectâ card, N...
- East Valley Tribune - Arizona Local News on Astini...
- Pan-Seared Chicken with Chicory, Bacon & Figs on A...
- Tax filing relief to those hurt by Hurricane Irene...
- DTS and Huawei Showcase Superior Audio Technologie...
- 'Paradise Lost' director Joe Berlinger sought just...
- Samsung Mobile Announces New Expansion of Galaxy F...
- 'Revolutionary,' Controversial Idea : NPR on Astin...
- J. Cole Is a Storyteller in 'Daddy's Little Girl' ...
- IIS 7.0 Detailed Error - 503.4 on Astini News
-
▼
September
(682)